“The Ukrainian and Russian peoples came out of the Dnieper baptismal font, and the war between these peoples is a repetition of the sin of Cain, who, out of envy, killed his own brother” His Beatitude, Metropolitan Onuphry of All Ukraine.
I have been working on another rather large article, which is close to being ready to publish when world events took a sharp turn. I will be posting the other article soon, but a number of people have reached out to me for my thought on what is transpiring in Ukraine. For whatever my thoughts are worth, I’m sharing a few of them in this post.
In the past I have written a number of articles that touch upon ecclesiastical issues in Ukraine, those articles may be found here.
Many are worried now that some “hot war” actions have begun in Ukraine, understandably and rightly so. Yet, speaking first to my Orthodox brethren, most of all I assume in America, I would say, the current issues have spiritual roots. Have we as Orthodox not been at best fairly passive with regard to what has been a type of spiritual fratricide in Ukraine? The spiritual fabric of Orthodoxy has been rent through the actions of the Ecumenical Patriarchate (EP) in recognizing unrepentant schismatics. As I’ve noted before, for years now violence has been used by these false christians against the faithful of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church under Met. Onuphry (Many Years!). At best flaccid support has been given by some here to the faithful there, mostly because those in America do not want to rock the boat. The representative of the Ecumenical Patriarchate in America, Archbp. Elpidophoros is an avid supporter of the schismatics in Ukraine. He openly communes and supports them. Yet he remains as head of the “Assembly of Canonical Bishops” in America. How can such a thing be? Few it seems have cared, up until now, that the faithful of Ukraine are being subjected to spiritual violence (which has manifested physically). Few it seems have cared that the EP is in open and full communion with unrepentant schismatics. So spiritual violence has been ravaging Ukraine, and few have said much. We value a nominal “peace” above true peace, for true peace cannot be had in communion with false brethren. Now major physical violence is taking place, but what is worse for the soul, spiritual or material violence?
Could it be that the assault on the spiritual peace of Ukraine has affected its physical peace?
How many Americans have been aware that there has been an effective civil war in eastern Ukraine since 2014? How many of us were concerned when Ukrainians were shooting at and killing Ukrainians? Was that okay?
As an American, I will speak to my country. I’m not in Russia. I don’t support the attack. But, we, as Americans, should ask ourselves – is Russia doing anything much different than our own country has done? When in the 21st century alone have we “respected” other nations’ sovereign boards? (Look at our southern border at current!) At the end of the 20th century, it was a US-led NATO that dismantled Yugoslavia. New borders, created by the US and friends, were established. These borders served US interests. Let us look at the Middle East, when did we respect borders there? The US has stated and acted upon the notion – if a leader is deemed bad and against “freedom and democracy,” it is a duty to overthrow such a leader and carve up the country as the Western powers see fit. When we do it, it is “good.” When Russia does the same thing, it is bad. (Again I’m not justifying anything, I’m making an analogy.) The US government is the epitome of the pot calling the kettle black, as are most of the European powers. Let us as Americans reflect that in this century alone our government waged almost none stop war since 2001. The US government has been in conflict with some countries or states for two decades. If we go back and count the years starting from the end of World War II, the number of years of war or conflict involving the US government is much more than the number of years with no conflict. And we are going to lecture the world on peace? All that to say, we are guilty of the very things we accuse Russia of doing. I guess that is called hypocrisy. The finger we are pointing at Russia is dripping with blood. Maybe we should wash our own hands first.
I’m an American. I honor my country, but I do not support the agenda of war and violence driving much of foreign policy. I’m very grieved by it. Let us take care of our own house first. As in many places, I do not think the government always reflects the people. I think most people want peace and to live their daily lives in calm. Sadly, there are many in power who are hell-bent on stirring up conflict and trouble for the world and people at large. We should also realize that US foreign policy has also played a role in cultivating the current events in Ukraine.
I think that a part of what is transpiring is the typical distraction tactic. The Covid crisis has revealed that the “free” West is not as “free” as it claims. Many Western countries went full dictator mode, thus revealing their true colors. Oh, yes, of course, to keep us all safe because they care for us from their million-dollar mansions. America is in deep crisis and turmoil, much of it fed by certain agendas that are actively seeking to encourage fear, hatred, and division. Our own house is tumbling and corroding away. Oh, but look! That dastardly Putin! He’s a new Hitler. I guess it takes one to know one. In America, the attempt is being made to distract us again. And yes some are insane enough to pursue a war with Russia to do so. I don’t know how far the events will go, but I do know from history that war is a great distraction and even a wonderful tool for “rebuilding” the world.
Of course, one could wander down the labyrinth of geopolitical agendas. I’m familiar with a number of them. I won’t do that right now. The historic discrimination of the Western world against Orthodoxy could be noted as an aspect also. But that is a big subject.
In closing to this my few thoughts, I will return to the spiritual aspect.
What can we as Christians do? Repent. Russia, for all its problems, is not our enemy.
Have we in America repented of the many wars and atrocities perpetrated in the name of our country? Should we not start there? Are we repenting for the “legal” slaughter of babies in their mother’s womb? Are we repenting for the open promotion, in the name of our country, of numerous forms of debauchery and immorality? Are we repenting for the epidemic of drug abuse and suicide in our nation? Are we repenting for being the top exporter of corrosive “culture” and “values?” Are we repenting for the destruction of the family and the explosion of divorce, adultery, fornication, and porn? This list could go on. It seems our own house is full of enemies.
As Orthodox are we repenting of the active attack on the Church that has taken place? Led by those who are themselves supposedly Orthodox? Have we repented of giving a place to unrepentant schismatics and their supporters? Have we repented of open communion, against the spirit of the Church and Her canons, with false brethren? Have we repented of ecumenism?
I think we have a lot we need to work on.
My heart breaks for the people of Ukraine. I am praying. I have friends and family there. What is transpiring there is not a “Russian” problem, it is an “all of us” problem. Welcome to a globalized world. As Orthodox, we have for the most part passively allowed the spiritual crisis in Ukraine to fester, hoping that if nothing is really done it will just go away. That has not happened. The bitter fruits are just growing. The world will only grow what men sow into it. If we do not like the fruit, then we must be careful of what we are sowing.
May our Lord truly grant us peace. May He, through the prayers of His Most-Pure Mother, soften the hearts of evil men.
10 thoughts on “A Reflection on Ukraine, America, Russia, and War”
Plus consider the complicity of the U.S. in creating the conflict in the first place by using the cover of the Olympics to install a regime friendly to us on the doorstep of Russia, thereby threatening Russian national interests
Yes, the events of Maidan may be considered the recent starting point that eventually festered into the current conflict/war. Very true that the US policy of guiding Ukraine into an aggressive anti-Russian stance is very much a fault for what is transpiring.
Americans, unfortunately do not care for Ukraine. They just do what the media says.
I am not against the measures Russia had to eventually take.
Dear Fr. Lynch
This is a wonderful article and speaks to the history of Russia and Ukraine. I am a deacon in an Orthodox church with a fair amount of Russians and maybe one or two Ukrainians. I feel very confused, distressed about how to feel. I consider myself a bit of a Russophile, I have studied the Russian language for 2 1/2-3 years, I have a love of the culture, and their food. My heart hurts for the Russian people as well as the Ukrainians. I just don’t know how to feel about all of this. Everything seems so anti-Russian from politics, to economics, to even sports. How do we or should we look at these issues through an Orthodox lens?
LikeLiked by 1 person
We hold to that which is good and beautiful. There is so much richness in Orthodoxy in the Rus’ian lands. World leaders come and go, yet the truth of Christ remains forever. Let us cherish the great treasure of Orthodoxy as it has been manifest in the current territories of Russia and Ukraine.
Nothing can justify Putin’s attack on the innocent people of Ukraine!
The point is not justification, rather in America that we would reflect on our county’s part in the tragedy.
The people are usually innocent; the leaders, not so much. The President of the Ukraine is a puppet of the U.S. government; the installation of his regime on the borders of a foreign power was an act intended to lead to conflict. Hard to find anyone wearing the white hat in this situation.
Pingback: A Reflection on Ukraine, America, Russia, and War – Biz Patriot
Pingback: Russia-Ukraine: Through a Dixian Lens, Part 1 - Identity Dixie